Immigration in America: Tomato Soup Or Tossed Salad?

In 1620, approximately 100 Pilgrims set sail to a new world in search of religious freedom.  For centuries after the Plymouth Rock landing, and in the 19th and early 20th centuries, immigrants arrived from Italy, Greece, Poland, Germany, Ireland and other foreign lands in search of what would become the American Dream.  This migration continued until 1882 when the federal government began to control immigration.  The exclusion consisted of prostitutes, criminals, alcoholics, and Chinese, among others, from coming to our country.  The federal government has been trying to redefine our immigration policies ever since. Today, the “U.S. immigration law is very complex, and there is much confusion as to how it works.”

For centuries, immigrants have come to America and brought their cultures with them.  Because of the European immigration, we have many wonderfully delicious and various foods.  We get to share in German Beer Gardens and Greek festivals.  They celebrated becoming Americans by becoming a legal citizen and learning English and were proud and anxious to share their cultures with us.  We can see the imprint of their influences throughout our country today.  For the most part, we Americans welcomed them with open arms and have been proud to call ourselves a “melting pot.”

Russian Jewish immigrant, Israel Zangwill, coined the term “melting pot” based on the meaning that new immigrants were encouraged to assimilate into our culture.

So are we still a “melting pot”?  In one case, Harvard professor Samuel Huntington instead refers to America as “tomato soup”.  According to Huntington, America was established not by immigrants but by settlers who inherited culture from white Anglo-Saxon Protestants — WASPs.  They, in turn, handed down to us the preeminence of individualism, English law and tradition, limited government, civic morality and the Protestant work ethic.  Huntington asserted that these “core cultural values are under threat because of an influx of immigrants and their unassimilated cultures.  A nation without a core culture won’t endure; hence, non-assimilation is bad news for him.”

Huntington saw immigrants as “spices” and wanted to “mix them up to serve as a cup of tomato soup.”

The newest and more popular term for America’s identify is a “salad bowl” or “tossed salad,” also known as multiculturalism whereby newcomers assimilate into our culture while holding onto their own country’s national characteristics.

Whether you agree with Professor Huntington that we are “tomato soup” or agree with pop culture that we are a “salad bowl,” one thing for certain: America is changing.  In Southern California, our multicultural society can serve up just about any kind of ethnic food you can think of and offer you a place of worship for a variety of religions.

However, the bottom line is that we were founded on Judeo- Christian principles and if a newcomer would like to assimilate into our society, they should first become a citizen of the United States of America, learn to speak English, learn our history as it really was, not from revisionist historians, and respect our core Judeo-Christian values as previous immigrants have done.  By not learning English, our history and our values, we will become a nation more in peril than we are now.

We have other big fish to fry based on the latest news about the Federal Reserve’s Quantitative Easing (QE3), but we have to always be mindful of our immigration problem.

On June 16, 1858 at 5:00 p.m. in the Springfield, Illinois Statehouse, more than 1,000 Republican delegates met for the Republican State Convention.  They chose Abraham Lincoln as their candidate for the U.S. Senate, running against Democrat Stephen A. Douglas.

There, Lincoln delivered an address in which he quoted Jesus from Matthew 12:25:  “A House divided against itself cannot stand,” Lincoln said, “and Jesus knew their thoughts, and said unto them, Every kingdom divided against itself is brought to desolation; and every city or house divided against itself shall not stand.”

Those are definitely words we can use today in 2012.



Lainie Sloane

Lainie Sloane started her grassroots political activism as a Teen Age Republican (TAR) when she was 14 years old, helping her local College Republicans. In addition to serving on various local and state campaign committees and managing GOP Campaign Headquarters for two presidential elections, Lainie was awarded an Indiana Honorary Indiana Secretary of State for her extraordinary leadership skills and dedication to maintaining our freedoms. After she married Los Angeles native and former entertainer, J.P. Sloane, Lainie worked in management at Sony Pictures, Walt Disney Company, Warner Bros. Animation and assisted in the development and start-up of a retro record label with Dick Clark Productions and Brown Sugar Productions. Recently, her political activities consisted of being on the leadership team for California Assemblyman Tim Donnelly's gubernatorial campaign and co-hosted a Blog Talk Radio Show, Vast Right Wing Conspiracy. She resides in Southern California with her husband, Dr. J.P. Sloane and their daughter, Shannon Sloane, where she is a music publishing business consultant and works as an insurance broker and assists her husband, Dr. Sloane, in the final editing stages of his book, The God of the Bible Is Not Allah, a condensed three-volume course exposing Islam, including select surahs from the Koran in a parallel Bible-Koran format. Lainie can be contacted at and on Twitter @LainieSGP.

Related Articles

Back to top button

Please disable ad blocker.

We work hard to write our articles and provide you with the content you enjoy. The ads on the site allow us to continue our work while feeding our families. If you'd please whitelist our site in your ad blocker or remove your ad blocker altogether, we'd greatly appreciate it. Thank you!